For the last few years, I've been enjoying an NFL playoffs fantasy league. Rules seem to differ from league to league, but ours only lets each manager select a maximum of two players from each team. Other than that, it's basically your standard PPR fantasy football scoring. The twist is the strategy around predicting how many games each team will play.

The playoffs bring unique challenges and opportunities for fantasy football players. Unlike the regular season, where the focus is on weekly consistency, playoffs fantasy requires balancing team success probabilities with player performance. Our projections look at how to optimize your fantasy lineup by predicting each player’s total expected points based on their team's probability of advancing through each playoff round.

Note: It should be obvious, but be careful with backup players (especially QBs) with a high point total. Their "average" isn't going to be very accurate if they didn't play in very many games.

PlayerPositionTeamAVG FPPWild Card RoundDivisional RoundConference FinalSuper BowlProj. Fantasy Points
Lamar JacksonQBBAL25.625.6021.3214.036.4067
Josh AllenQBBUF22.622.6018.5012.665.7960
Derrick HenryRBBAL19.819.8016.4910.854.9552
Saquon BarkleyRBPHI22.222.2014.998.594.9351
Jalen HurtsQBPHI21.321.3014.388.244.7349
Jahmyr GibbsRBDET21.30.0021.3014.219.4745
James CookRBBUF16.716.7013.679.354.2844
Baker MayfieldQBTB22.522.5014.385.001.7344
Jared GoffQBDET19.80.0019.8013.218.8042
Amon-Ra St. BrownWRDET18.60.0018.6012.418.2739
A.J. BrownWRPHI16.716.7011.286.463.7138
Patrick Mahomes IIQBKC18.40.0018.4011.897.6738
Sam DarnoldQBMIN18.818.8010.224.912.3536
Jimmy GaroppoloQBLAR20.920.9010.153.761.3936
Justin JeffersonWRMIN18.718.7010.164.882.3436
DeVonta SmithWRPHI15.315.3010.335.923.4035
Jayden DanielsQBWAS21.521.508.633.121.1334
Rashee RiceWRKC16.20.0016.2010.476.7533
David MontgomeryRBDET15.80.0015.8010.547.0233
Mike EvansWRTB17.217.2010.993.821.3233
Chris GodwinWRTB17.217.2010.993.821.3233
Tanner McKeeQBPHI14.414.409.725.573.2033
Puka NacuaWRLAR18.818.809.133.381.2533
Zay FlowersWRBAL12.312.3010.246.743.0832
Khalil ShakirWRBUF12.212.209.996.833.1332
Justin HerbertQBLAC17.017.0010.283.421.1332
Jameson WilliamsWRDET14.10.0014.109.406.2730
Kyren WilliamsRBLAR17.017.008.253.061.1329
Mark AndrewsTEBAL11.111.109.246.082.7829
Josh JacobsRBGB17.217.206.123.512.0229
Ladd McConkeyWRLAC15.115.109.133.041.0128
Bucky IrvingRBTB14.414.409.203.201.1128
Nico CollinsWRHOU17.617.607.492.130.6128
J.K. DobbinsRBLAC14.814.808.952.970.9928
Aaron Jones Sr.RBMIN14.214.207.723.711.7827
Jordan AddisonWRMIN14.214.207.723.711.7827
Daniel JonesQBMIN14.214.207.723.711.7827
Jordan LoveQBGB16.316.305.803.331.9227
Joe MixonRBHOU17.217.207.322.080.5927
Rashod BatemanWRBAL10.310.308.585.642.5827
Bo NixQBDEN19.419.404.251.880.8426
Cooper KuppWRLAR14.614.607.092.630.9725
Terry McLaurinWRWAS15.815.806.352.290.8325
Travis KelceTEKC12.20.0012.207.885.0825
Kareem HuntRBKC12.00.0012.007.755.0025
Marcus MariotaQBWAS15.315.306.142.220.8124
Rachaad WhiteRBTB12.512.507.992.780.9624
Matthew StaffordQBLAR13.913.906.752.500.9324
Stefon DiggsWRHOU15.215.206.471.840.5224
Dallas GoedertTEPHI10.410.407.024.022.3124
Amari CooperWRBUF8.88.807.204.932.2623
Sam LaPortaTEDET10.90.0010.907.274.8423
Xavier WorthyWRKC11.00.0011.007.114.5823
Tyler BassKBUF8.68.607.044.822.2123
Keon ColemanWRBUF8.68.607.044.822.2123
Justice HillRBBAL8.58.507.084.662.1322
Justin TuckerKBAL8.48.407.004.602.1022
Quentin JohnstonWRLAC11.611.607.022.330.7722
C.J. StroudQBHOU13.713.705.831.660.4722
Russell WilsonQBPIT16.216.203.321.360.5621
Dalton KincaidTEBUF7.87.806.384.372.0021
Buffalo BillsDSTBUF7.87.806.384.372.0021
Austin SeibertKWAS12.812.805.141.860.6720
Isaiah LikelyTEBAL7.77.706.414.221.9320
Jalen McMillanWRTB10.410.406.652.310.8020
Jake BatesKDET9.50.009.506.344.2220
Cameron DickerKLAC10.510.506.352.110.7020
Will ReichardKMIN10.110.105.492.641.2619
Jayden ReedWRGB11.611.604.132.371.3619
Cade OttonTETB10.010.006.392.220.7719
Courtland SuttonWRDEN14.114.103.091.370.6119
DeAndre HopkinsWRKC9.20.009.205.943.8319
Jake ElliottKPHI8.38.305.613.211.8419
Marquise BrownWRKC9.10.009.105.883.7919
Baltimore RavensDSTBAL7.17.105.913.891.7819
Chase McLaughlinKTB9.69.606.132.130.7419
Minnesota VikingsDSTMIN9.59.505.162.481.1918
Brian Robinson Jr.RBWAS11.411.404.581.650.6018
Philadelphia EaglesDSTPHI7.97.905.343.061.7618
Ray DavisRBBUF6.86.805.573.811.7418
Austin EkelerRBWAS11.011.004.421.600.5818
Romeo DoubsWRGB10.210.203.632.081.2017
T.J. HockensonTEMIN8.78.704.732.271.0917
Isiah PachecoRBKC8.10.008.105.233.3817
Zach ErtzTEWAS10.410.404.181.510.5517
Tucker KraftTEGB9.69.603.421.961.1316
Ka'imi FairbairnKHOU10.110.104.301.220.3516
Harrison ButkerKKC7.70.007.704.973.2116
Najee HarrisRBPIT12.012.002.461.010.4116
Justin FieldsQBPIT12.012.002.461.010.4116
Tank DellWRHOU10.010.004.261.210.3416
George PickensWRPIT11.711.702.400.980.4015
Tyler HigbeeTELAR8.98.904.321.600.5915
Mack HollinsWRBUF5.85.804.753.251.4915
Detroit LionsDSTDET7.20.007.204.803.2015
Brandon McManusKGB9.09.003.201.841.0615
Chris BoswellKPIT11.211.202.300.940.3915
Green Bay PackersDSTGB8.78.703.101.771.0215
Denver BroncosDSTDEN10.510.502.301.020.4614
Ty JohnsonRBBUF5.45.404.423.021.3814
Los Angeles ChargersDSTLAC7.57.504.541.510.5014
Noah GrayTEKC6.70.006.704.332.7914
Joshua KartyKLAR7.97.903.831.420.5314
Will DisslyTELAC7.37.304.411.470.4914
Joshua PalmerWRLAC7.27.204.351.450.4813
Spencer ShraderKKC6.50.006.504.202.7113
Pat FreiermuthTEPIT9.99.902.030.830.3413
Houston TexansDSTHOU8.28.203.490.990.2813
Kansas City ChiefsDSTKC6.20.006.204.012.5813
Wil LutzKDEN9.49.402.060.910.4113
Demarcus RobinsonWRLAR7.37.303.541.310.4913
Javonte WilliamsRBDEN9.39.302.040.900.4013
Noah BrownWRWAS7.87.803.131.130.4112
Malik WillisQBGB7.47.402.631.510.8712
Tim PatrickWRDET5.80.005.803.872.5812
Curtis SamuelWRBUF4.64.603.772.581.1812
Tyrell ShaversWRBUF4.64.603.772.581.1812
Los Angeles RamsDSTLAR6.96.903.351.240.4612
Kenny PickettQBPHI5.25.203.512.011.1612
Tampa Bay BuccaneersDSTTB6.16.103.901.350.4712
Jalen NailorWRMIN6.16.103.311.590.7612
Christian WatsonWRGB7.07.002.491.430.8212
Diontae JohnsonWRHOU7.47.403.150.900.2612
Pittsburgh SteelersDSTPIT8.68.601.760.720.3011
Cam AkersRBMIN5.85.803.151.510.7311
Devaughn VeleWRDEN8.28.201.790.800.3611
Dalton SchultzTEHOU7.07.002.980.850.2411
Sterling ShepardWRTB5.75.703.641.270.4411
Jaylen WarrenRBPIT8.38.301.700.700.2911
Dontayvion WicksWRGB6.56.502.311.330.7611
Gus EdwardsRBLAC5.85.803.511.170.3911
Olamide ZaccheausWRWAS6.66.602.650.960.3511
Marvin Mims Jr.WRDEN7.67.601.660.740.3310
Zane GonzalezKWAS6.36.302.530.910.3310
Tutu AtwellWRLAR5.85.802.821.040.3910
Kalif RaymondWRDET4.70.004.703.132.0910
Samaje PerineRBKC4.80.004.803.102.0010
Dawson KnoxTEBUF3.73.703.032.070.9510
Emanuel WilsonRBGB5.65.601.991.140.669
Calvin Austin IIIWRPIT7.07.001.430.590.249
Nelson AgholorWRBAL3.53.502.911.920.889
Josh OliverTEMIN4.44.402.391.150.558
Washington CommandersDSTWAS5.35.302.130.770.288
Jaleel McLaughlinRBDEN6.16.101.330.590.278
Kenneth GainwellRBPHI3.63.602.431.390.808
Grant CalcaterraTEPHI3.53.502.361.350.788
JuJu Smith-SchusterWRKC3.80.003.802.451.588
Sean TuckerRBTB4.04.002.560.890.318
Justin WatsonWRKC3.70.003.702.391.548
Tyler JohnsonWRLAR4.14.101.990.740.277
Jamison CrowderWRWAS4.44.401.770.640.237
Parris CampbellWRPHI3.03.002.031.160.677
John Metchie IIIWRHOU4.34.301.830.520.157
Dyami BrownWRWAS4.24.201.690.610.227
Colby ParkinsonTELAR3.83.801.840.680.257
Ryan MillerWRTB3.33.302.110.730.256
Dameon PierceRBHOU4.04.001.700.480.146
Chris Rodriguez Jr.RBWAS3.93.901.570.570.216
Kimani VidalRBLAC3.33.302.000.660.226
Jeremy McNicholsRBWAS3.83.801.530.550.206
Jordan WhittingtonWRLAR3.53.501.700.630.236
Charlie KolarTEBAL2.22.201.831.210.556
Mecole Hardman Jr.WRKC2.80.002.801.811.176
Jahan DotsonWRPHI2.52.501.690.970.566
Ainias SmithWRPHI2.52.501.690.970.566
Troy FranklinWRDEN4.24.200.920.410.186
Tylan WallaceWRBAL2.12.101.751.150.536
Devin CulpTETB2.82.801.790.620.225
Chris BrooksRBGB3.23.201.140.650.385
Dare OgunbowaleRBHOU3.33.301.400.400.115
Johnny MundtTEMIN2.72.701.470.700.345
Lil'Jordan HumphreyWRDEN3.83.800.830.370.175
Derius DavisWRLAC2.72.701.630.540.185
Audric EstimeRBDEN3.73.700.810.360.165
Van JeffersonWRPIT3.73.700.760.310.135
Britain CoveyWRPHI2.12.101.420.810.475
MarShawn LloydRBGB2.82.801.000.570.335
Ronnie RiversRBLAR2.62.601.260.470.175
Mitchell TrubiskyQBBUF1.71.701.390.950.444
Keaton MitchellRBBAL1.71.701.420.930.434
Trey PalmerWRTB2.32.301.470.510.184
Brock WrightTEDET2.10.002.101.400.934
Jermar JeffersonRBDET2.10.002.101.400.934
Malik HeathWRGB2.62.600.930.530.314
Stone SmarttTELAC2.32.301.390.460.154
Payne DurhamTETB2.22.201.410.490.174
Mike WilliamsWRPIT3.23.200.660.270.114
Tyler BadieRBDEN3.13.100.680.300.134
Hassan HaskinsRBLAC2.22.201.330.440.154
Robert WoodsWRHOU2.62.601.110.310.094
Rakim JarrettWRTB2.12.101.340.470.164
Simi FehokoWRLAC2.12.101.270.420.144
Cordarrelle PattersonRBPIT2.92.900.590.240.104
Blake CorumRBLAR2.22.201.070.400.154
Davis MillsQBHOU2.42.401.020.290.084
K.J. OsbornWRWAS2.32.300.920.330.124
Ty ChandlerRBMIN1.91.901.030.500.244
Cade StoverTEHOU2.32.300.980.280.084
DJ Chark Jr.WRLAC1.91.901.150.380.134
Adam TrautmanTEDEN2.62.600.570.250.114
Nate AdkinsTEDEN2.62.600.570.250.114
Lucas KrullTEDEN2.62.600.570.250.114
Darnell WashingtonTEPIT2.62.600.530.220.093
Devontez WalkerWRBAL1.31.301.080.710.333
Anthony MillerWRBAL1.31.301.080.710.333
Jalen ReagorWRLAC1.81.801.090.360.123
Carson WentzQBKC1.60.001.601.030.673
Cody SchraderRBLAR1.91.900.920.340.133
Luke McCaffreyWRWAS2.02.000.800.290.113
Hayden HurstTELAC1.71.701.030.340.113
Craig ReynoldsRBDET1.50.001.501.000.673
Carson SteeleRBKC1.50.001.500.970.633
Tyquan ThorntonWRKC1.50.001.500.970.633
Mike WhiteQBBUF1.11.100.900.620.283
Peyton HendershotTEKC1.40.001.400.900.583
Nikko RemigioWRKC1.40.001.400.900.583
Will ShipleyRBPHI1.21.200.810.460.273
Luke MusgraveTEGB1.61.600.570.330.193
Patrick RicardRBBAL1.01.000.830.550.253
J.J. TaylorRBHOU1.61.600.680.190.063
Trent Sherfield Sr.WRMIN1.31.300.710.340.163
Xavier HutchinsonWRHOU1.51.500.640.180.052
Quintin MorrisTEBUF0.90.900.740.500.232
Michael BurtonRBDEN1.71.700.370.160.072
E.J. JenkinsTEPHI1.01.000.680.390.222
Tucker FiskTELAC1.21.200.730.240.082
Brevin JordanTEHOU1.41.400.600.170.052
Bo MeltonWRGB1.31.300.460.270.152
Johnny WilsonWRPHI0.90.900.610.350.202
Hendon HookerQBDET0.90.000.900.600.402
MyCole PruittTEPIT1.31.300.270.110.042
Laviska Shenault Jr.WRLAC0.90.900.540.180.062
Tyrion Davis-PriceRBPHI0.70.700.470.270.162
Ben SkowronekWRPIT1.21.200.250.100.042
Rasheen AliRBBAL0.60.600.500.330.152
Brandon PowellWRMIN0.80.800.430.210.102
C.J. HamRBMIN0.80.800.430.210.102
Taylor HeinickeQBLAC0.80.800.480.160.051
Blake WatsonRBDEN1.11.100.240.110.051
Sione VakiRBDET0.70.000.700.470.311
Hunter LongTELAR0.80.800.390.140.051
Zach DavidsonTEBUF0.50.500.410.280.131
John BatesTEWAS0.80.800.320.120.041
Ben SinnottTEWAS0.80.800.320.120.041
Davis AllenTELAR0.70.700.340.130.051
Connor HeywardTEPIT0.90.900.180.080.031
Scotty MillerWRPIT0.90.900.180.080.031
Kyle AllenQBPIT0.80.800.160.070.031
Allen Robinson IIWRDET0.50.000.500.330.221
Jody Fortson Jr.TEKC0.50.000.500.320.211
Chris OladokunQBKC0.50.000.500.320.211
Ben SimsTEGB0.50.500.180.100.061
Jonathan WardRBPIT0.60.600.120.050.021
Brandon JohnsonWRPIT0.60.600.120.050.021
Aaron ShampklinRBPIT0.60.600.120.050.021
Xavier SmithWRLAR0.40.400.190.070.031
Brycen TremayneWRWAS0.40.400.160.060.021
Shane ZylstraTEDET0.30.000.300.200.131
Nick MullensQBMIN0.30.300.160.080.041
Eric TomlinsonTELAC0.30.300.180.060.021
Jared WileyTEKC0.20.000.200.130.080
Kameron JohnsonWRTB0.20.200.130.040.020
Jarrett StidhamQBDEN0.20.200.040.020.010
Reggie GilliamRBBUF0.10.100.080.060.030
Josh JohnsonQBBAL0.10.100.080.050.030
John FitzPatrickTEGB0.10.100.040.020.010
British BrooksRBHOU0.10.100.040.010.000
Kyle TraskQBTB-0.1-0.10-0.06-0.02-0.010
Steven Sims Jr.WRBAL-0.2-0.20-0.17-0.11-0.05-1

Our Methodology: Probability-Weighted Projections

To create accurate player projections, we analyzed the odds for each team to advance to each round of the playoffs. We could adjust player projections by assigning probabilities to each team’s path. Players on teams likely to make a deep playoff run have higher overall projections, while those on teams with lower probabilities of advancing beyond the Wild Card round see their values decrease.

Key Factors Considered:

  • Team Probabilities: The likelihood of a team advancing to each round based on current betting odds.
  • Player Performance: Historical per-game fantasy points for each player.
  • Bye Weeks: Teams with a first-round bye (Kansas City and Detroit) potentially have fewer games but also a higher probability of advancing past the Divisional Round.
  • Matchup Adjustments: Factoring in potential matchups, which could influence player performance in each round.

The Impact of Bye Weeks

While teams with a first-round bye are more likely to win their first playoff game, they also have one fewer game to accumulate fantasy points. This makes bye-week players both high-risk and high-reward. For example, Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City) and Amon-Ra St. Brown (Detroit) are top-tier options, but their reduced total game count needs to be factored into your strategy.

Strategy for Building Your Playoffs Fantasy Team

  1. Balance High-Probability and Long-Shot Players: While top-tier players from teams like Kansas City and Philadelphia are must-haves, adding players from underdog teams can provide a high upside if those teams make unexpected runs.
  2. Stacking Players from the Same Team: In playoffs fantasy, stacking (selecting multiple players from the same team) can be a winning strategy. If your chosen team makes it to the Super Bowl, your lineup will crush. Again, this is a high-risk, high-reward strategy and may not be an option based on your league’s rules.
  3. Diversify Your Roster: Avoid putting all your eggs in one basket. Select players from different teams to hedge against early eliminations. This may already be built into your rules if you can’t select more than a certain number of players from each team.
  4. Consider Matchups: Look ahead at potential playoff matchups. Favor players whose teams have favorable paths to the Super Bowl or face a team that struggles against their particular skill set.

Playoffs fantasy football is a way to extend your fantasy football season that combines skill, strategy, and a bit of luck. By leveraging our probability-weighted projections and understanding the impact of bye weeks and potential matchups, you can build a lineup primed for success. Whether targeting top-tier stars or hunting for value among underdogs, the key is to stay flexible.

Good luck, and may your playoff fantasy team go the distance!